Welcome to Carlos Pizza and Bar
Experience the warm, inviting taste of classic Italian tradition right here in Middletown. Join us for specialty pizzas, hearty pastas, and a cozy dine-in experience.
Our Middletown Favorites
Discover the beloved dishes our community comes back for, from our signature specialty pizzas to our comforting, hearty pasta dinners.
Personal Pizza
Add your Favorite Toppings
Pasta With Vodka Sauce
Garlic Knots 6
Explore Our Menu
Whether you are craving a traditional slice, a generous plate of pasta, or a perfectly poured drink from our full bar, we have something to make you feel right at home.
Poultry Dishes
Chicken dinners prepared Carlos style, from parmigiana and Marsala to Francese, picatta, cacciatore, broccoli, Florentina, Saltimbocca, and gluten-free parm
Plain Pizzas
Build from the classics with large, medium, personal, Sicilian, pan, cauliflower, gluten-free, and heart-shaped plain pizzas made for every appetite
Seafood
Seafood dinners featuring shrimp, clams, salmon, scampi, marinara, Alfredo, fra diavolo, vodka sauce, broccoli, and Carlos seafood combo plates.
Heart Shapez Pizza
Heart-shaped pizzas for special occasions, available as plain or specialty-style pies when you want a fun Carlos pizza made for sharing together
Specialty Pizzas
Carlos specialty pies include Margherita, white, Grandma, meat lovers, Supreme, Buffalo chicken, BBQ chicken, vodka, taco, tortellini, and veggie pizzas
From The Grill
Grilled comfort favorites including cheesesteaks, burgers, Carlos sandwiches, and California-style builds for a hot, casual meal off the grill
Traditional Italian, Cozy Atmosphere
At Carlos Pizza and Bar (also known as Carlos Cucina), we believe in serving food that brings people together. Our Middletown location offers a warm, friendly environment where friends and family can gather over high-quality ingredients and authentic Italian recipes.
Enjoy our cozy, vintage-inspired dining room with a beautiful full bar, or let us bring the taste of Carlos to you through our reliable local delivery and professional event catering. Hospitality and freshness are at the heart of everything we do.
